电脑版魔域学术科研互动平台

投稿14天后论文被拒,电脑版魔域但是编辑让修改后重投,三个审稿人评价如下:
Reviewer's Responses to Questions
Please rate the importance compared to published work in this subject area
Reviewer #1: Considerable (Top 50%)
Reviewer #2: Outstanding (Top 5%)
Reviewer #3: Moderate (Bottom 50%)
--------------------
Please rate the novelty compared to published work in this subject area
Reviewer #1: Considerable (Top 50%)
Reviewer #2: High (Top 20%)
Reviewer #3: Moderate (Bottom 50%)

其中第一第二个审稿人评价挺正面的,第三个审稿人建议拒稿,建议转投SMALL,主要问题是电池电化学性能提升不明显。跟老师讨论了一下,决定大修。电化学性能其实我在做的时候就知道不是很好,没办法做到文献报道的那么高,主要原因是设备受限,现在打算换实验方法重新做,希望能坚持下来有个好结果。
 

2025-11-25 19:58 点击量:2